How do you choose an emulsifier for a skincare formula? Most formulators were taught HLB, and better tools now exist for the same job: PIT and HLD. For multi-active formulas there is also a newer question HLB never asked: where each active should go. That is the question TDA Logic answers.
The Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance was published by William Griffin at Atlas Powder Company in 1949. It gave formulators one number per emulsifier and one simple goal: match the emulsifier to the oil so the emulsion holds. Seventy-five years later, most cosmetic emulsions are still designed that way, and most formulators were trained on it.
HLB has well-known limits. It does not account for temperature, salt, pH or the real behavior of a specific oil. Colloid scientists have spent decades building better tools to fix that. At the same time, modern formulas have changed in a way HLB was never designed for: one serum now carries peptides, vitamins, humectants, lipids and botanicals at once, each with its own chemistry. This article lays out the four frameworks side by side so you can see which question each one answers.
The original question
HLB: which emulsifier holds this oil in water?
Griffin's scale runs from 0 to 20 for nonionic emulsifiers. Low numbers favor water-in-oil, high numbers favor oil-in-water, and each oil phase has a "required HLB" that the emulsifier blend is matched to. It is fast, it is taught everywhere, and for many macro-emulsions it still works as a first screen.
Its limits are structural, not a matter of effort:
- It is one static number, so it cannot see temperature, electrolytes or pH.
- It treats the oil phase as a required value rather than describing how each oil actually behaves at the interface.
- It says nothing about particle size, surface charge or ionic strength.
- It selects an emulsifier. It never asks where each active ends up once the emulsion exists.
A better answer to the same question
PIT: when does the emulsion flip?
Kōzō Shinoda and Hiroshi Arai described the Phase Inversion Temperature in 1964. For emulsions stabilized by ethoxylated nonionic surfactants, heating shifts the surfactant's affinity from water toward oil until the emulsion inverts. Formulators use that transition to choose emulsifiers and to make fine emulsions with low energy input. PIT improves on HLB by making temperature a measured variable instead of an ignored one. It is still a tool for choosing and processing an emulsifier system.
The best answer to the same question
HLD and NAC: a thermodynamic model of the interface
The Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Difference grew out of Jean-Louis Salager's work on optimum formulation, published from 1979 onward. HLD combines surfactant character, oil character (as equivalent alkane carbon number, EACN), salinity, temperature and co-surfactant effects into one index. A value near zero marks the balanced point, negative values favor oil-in-water and positive values favor water-in-oil. In effect, HLD generalizes both HLB and PIT and carries salt explicitly.
Edgar Acosta and colleagues added the Net Average Curvature model in 2003. NAC uses HLD to predict solubilization capacity, interfacial tension and phase transitions. Together, HLD and NAC are the most rigorous way available to answer HLB's original question, and formulators working with difficult oils or electrolyte-heavy systems benefit from learning them.
A different question
TDA Logic: where does each active go?
TDA Logic (tri-domain architecture logic) starts where the other three stop. It assumes the colloidal structure is already built: three nanoscale domains, nanocolloidal, nanoliposomal and nanomicellar, designed to coexist in one continuous water phase. The formulator's job is no longer to pick an emulsifier. It is to place each ingredient by its own chemistry, using its logP or logD at the formula's pH, its solubility and its charge, and to keep each destination within its capacity.
There are four destinations:
- Continuous water phase: water-soluble ingredients such as humectants and many peptides, within an ionic-strength budget.
- Nanoliposomal bilayer: amphiphilic ingredients that anchor in a phospholipid bilayer.
- Nanomicellar domain: surface-active and solubilized ingredients.
- Nanocolloidal oil core: oils and high-logP lipophiles such as oil-soluble vitamins.
The domains are held apart by an electrostatic wall. Like-charged particle surfaces repel before they can merge, the charge-barrier mechanism described by Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey and Overbeek in the 1940s (DLVO theory). On NanoBase™, the only known TDA architecture ready to formulate with, that wall is verified by zeta potential at -41 mV, with particle size characterized by dynamic light scattering.
Because every active is placed where its chemistry belongs, every active is a hero. The formula itself becomes the delivery system, rather than one encapsulated raw material bought per active.
TDA Logic is not a thought experiment. It was defined at Pensive Beauty® Nanoscience Labs, and formulas built on it have been in commercial production since 2025, used by brands from indie labels to global companies. The full framework, with its placement rules and evidence status, is published at tdalogic.com, and the founding technical note is on Zenodo.
Side by side
Four frameworks, two questions
| Framework | Introduced | Question it answers | Key inputs | Best used for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HLB | Griffin, 1949 | Which emulsifier holds this oil in water? | Emulsifier HLB values, required HLB of the oil phase | Quick first screen for conventional macro-emulsions |
| PIT | Shinoda and Arai, 1964 | At what temperature does the emulsion invert? | Temperature behavior of nonionic surfactants | Selecting nonionic systems and low-energy fine emulsions |
| HLD and NAC | Salager, 1979 onward; Acosta et al., 2003 | Where is this surfactant, oil and water system balanced, and what will it solubilize? | Surfactant curvature, oil EACN, salinity, temperature | Difficult oils, electrolytes, microemulsions, rigorous emulsifier selection |
| TDA Logic | Pensive Beauty® Nanoscience Labs, 2025 | Where does each active go, and how much room is left there? | logP or logD at formula pH, solubility, charge, destination capacity | Multi-active formulas on a tri-domain nanoscale architecture |
So which one is the successor?
It depends on which question you are asking
If you are building a conventional cream and want the most accurate way to choose its emulsifier system, HLD and NAC are the modern answer, with PIT as a practical tool for nonionic systems. Learn them. They will make you a better emulsion formulator.
If you are formulating a multi-active serum, gel, lotion or cream and want each active placed by its chemistry, the emulsifier question is already answered by the architecture. The question that remains is placement, and that is the question TDA Logic was built to answer. In that sense TDA Logic is the successor to HLB logic for nanoscale cosmetic formulation: it replaces "which emulsifier?" with "which destination?"
The two are not rivals. Most formulators were trained on HLB, and that training still matters. TDA Logic simply moves the work from building a structure to using one. For a full, practical walkthrough, including your first formula on TDA Logic and how to convert an HLB formula step by step, see the book Formulating Beyond HLB.
Questions
Frequently asked
How do I choose an emulsifier for skincare?
Start with the oil phase and the format. HLB gives a quick first screen, PIT helps with nonionic systems and temperature, and HLD with NAC gives the most accurate prediction when oils, salts or temperature are difficult. If you formulate on a ready nanoscale architecture, the emulsifier choice is already made and the work becomes placing each active by its chemistry.
What is the successor to HLB?
For choosing emulsifiers, HLD and NAC are the modern thermodynamic successors, generalizing both HLB and PIT. For formulating on a nanoscale architecture, TDA Logic is the successor design logic: instead of asking which emulsifier holds the oil, it asks where each active should go among four destinations.
Is HLD better than HLB?
For emulsifier selection, yes. HLD accounts for oil character (EACN), salinity, temperature and surfactant curvature, which HLB ignores. Both still answer the same question, which emulsifier system stabilizes a given oil and water.
What is TDA Logic?
TDA Logic (tri-domain architecture logic) is a placement framework for formulating on a nanoscale architecture with nanocolloidal, nanoliposomal and nanomicellar domains in one continuous water phase. Each ingredient is assigned to the water phase, the bilayer, the micelle or the oil core by its logP or logD, solubility and charge. It was defined at Pensive Beauty® Nanoscience Labs.
Does TDA Logic replace HLD or PIT?
No. HLD and PIT help build an emulsion. TDA Logic is used once the structure already exists, to place the actives inside it.
Is TDA Logic used commercially?
Yes. Formulas built on TDA Logic have been in commercial production since 2025, on NanoBase™, the only known TDA architecture ready to formulate with.

